9
Human rights defenders said that simplicity, familiarity
and ease of use were by far the most important criteria
when choosing tools. Many used paper forms as their
primary form of information capture. Software tools like
Word and Excel were mentioned more than any others,
while Google Drive and Dropbox were often mentioned as
tools for sharing information and managing documents
online. Many HRDs knew of the potential security risks
associated with using tools like Google Drive (given
Google’s collaboration with the US government), but chose
to use it regardless.
Tools for collaborating on documents and files across
borders were particularly mentioned as a gap. Many
organisations rely upon Google Drive for ease, needing a
way of sharing and collaborating on the same document
in close to real time. The ease of setup (signing up for a
Google account) and the user friendly nature of the tools
and support documentation, along with the reliability of
the tools, made it a much more appealing choice for many
than a self-hosted alternative.
While the HRDs we spoke to worked throughout the
world (from regions including South and South-east Asia,
sub-Saharan Africa and the Middle East), tool developers
were generally based in Europe or the US. Many tool
developers described putting considerable effort and
thought into building tools specifically for HRDs, including
user testing and, in some cases, co-creation with partner
organisations.
However, the HRDs we spoke to (many of whom fitted
the profile of the tools’ intended users) found it hard to
identify a tool that was right for them, and chose the
tools that they did use in a relatively ad-hoc manner.1 It’s
worth noting that this tendency is common in many other
sectors, as shown by research from The Engine Room and
Making All Voices Count.
Most interviewees emphasised that many human rights
defenders are working in environments where resources
are scarce and where experience with technology is
limited. In those contexts, HRDs were unaware of more
complex, specialist technology tools, or found them
difficult or impossible to use.
1
Tool Selection research by The Engine Room:
https://toolselect.theengineroom.org/