witnesses. Seek documentation.
Legends are fine, and even fun, for athletes and fans reliving the glory days of a legendary
sports team. But journalists, activists or human rights workers must deal with the truth and
must be committed to finding and telling the truth, especially in an emergency situation.
Whether we’re assembling the tale of a natural disaster, a breaking news story or a bit of
popular lore, storytellers must remember that we hear the product of faulty memory or limited perspective. If telling the truth is our goal, verification must be our standard.
We need to look and listen earnestly to the stories of our sources, watching for opportunities
to verify. Does the source have a (new or old) video, photograph, letter or document that
can offer verification or detail, or perhaps correct a foggy memory? And when we’re supplied
with this material, especially in emergency situations where time is tight, we need to investigate it and apply the fundamentals of verification.
Regardless of the moment and your role in it, the principles of verification are timeless and
can be applied to any situation, be it breaking news, a natural disaster or the retelling of a
apocryphal tale from a quarter century earlier.
The Essence of Verification
One of journalism’s most treasured clichés, spouted by seasoned editors who ruthlessly
slash other clichés from stories, is: “If your mother says she loves you, check it out.”
But the cliché doesn’t tell the journalist, or humanitarian professional, how to check it out.
Verification is the essence of journalism, but it also illustrates the difficulty of journalism and
the need for high standards: The path to verification can vary with each fact.
So this handbook won’t present journalists, human rights workers and other emergency
responders with one-size-fits-all simple steps to verification, but with strategies to check it
out - whatever “it” is, and whatever motivation or role you have.
The question at the heart of verification is: “How do you know that?”
Reporters need to ask this question of their sources; editors need to ask it of reporters. Reporters, editors, producers and human rights workers need to ask the question in the third
person about sources they can’t ask directly: How do they know that?
Newsroom coach Rosalie Stemer adds a second question that illustrates the multilayered
process of verification and the ethic of persistence and resourcefulness that verification
demands: How else do you know that?
16