1 Relevance and Purpose of Digital Verification
1.1 Introduction
As technology advances, so too does our access to information on events taking place
around the world. The ready availability of mobile recording devices such as
smartphones, and the now global reach of communication and information, means
that evidence of suspected human rights violations can be gathered remotely,
without having to go into the field. A large amount of videos, images and other
pieces of content are either shared directly or uploaded to social media websites such
as Twitter, YouTube and Facebook. These platforms provide a rich source of content
that may be useful when seeking information on possible human rights violations.
However, this digital content is not always reliable. For example, it may have been
manipulated, or may not actually depict the event it claims. The purpose of this
guide is to help you, as a human rights defender, to verify digital video or
photographic content of alleged human rights violations. In this context, verifying
means determining not only whether a video or photo has been manipulated or is
authentic, but also evaluating its reliability. It is important to be aware that content
may have been uploaded for a specific purpose, resulting in bias. For example,
although accurate, a video may only depict a part of the overall events, excluding
relevant
information.
Effective
verification therefore
attempts to
gain an
understanding of all aspects of an event, instead of only focusing on the validity of
one piece of content. Verification is essential: only authenticated videos or photos
should be used for human rights documentation.
Verifying digital content and successfully documenting human rights violations can
be extremely difficult. This is partially due to the fact that this is still an evolving
discipline. On top of that, content available on the Internet is shared widely and
rapidly and is therefore often difficult to verify, as the original source of the content
can be hard to find.
This Guide will talk you through the verification process, and provide detailed
examples of issues faced and how to resolve them.
6